In a historic event for the Roman Catholic Church, Cardinal Robert Francis Prevost, now referred to as Pope Leo, became the first American to be elected to the papacy. He was chosen as the 267th pontiff on Thursday, May 8, and his inaugural Mass the next day was a moment of deep emotional and cultural importance for both the Catholic community and the global audience.
What genuinely fascinated audiences worldwide was Pope Leo’s choice to present his address in English during his inaugural Mass. His Chicago accent, which is atypical for a pope, took many by surprise and generated a significant response on social media. The immediate and extensive reaction to the American accent saw users on platforms such as X (formerly Twitter) expressing astonishment and even amusement at the Pope speaking in his native tongue.
Although Pope Leo’s decision to deliver his inaugural address in English was recognized for its uniqueness, the deeper significance of his election extends well beyond mere language. The 69-year-old pontiff’s history, convictions, and leadership style are certain to influence the future of the Catholic Church, as he integrates both American ideals and international viewpoints into the papacy.
Pope Leo, who was born in Chicago, Illinois, made history by becoming the first American elected as Pope. His election to the papacy occurred on May 8, 2025, shortly after the death of Pope Francis on Easter Monday (April 21, 2025). This selection followed a rapid conclave process in which 133 cardinals from across the globe cast their votes to choose him as the next spiritual leader of the Roman Catholic Church. The transition from the late Pope Francis to Pope Leo was seamless, with the new pontiff being widely viewed as a moderate dedicated to the social justice principles advocated by his predecessor.
Prior to his election, Cardinal Prevost, who is now Pope Leo, was recognized for his leadership in the Augustinian Order, a role that afforded him considerable influence within the Catholic community. As the Prior General of the Order of St. Augustine, he was actively involved in efforts aimed at alleviating poverty, providing service, and promoting evangelization. His previous position also highlighted his enduring dedication to the poor and marginalized, a commitment he maintains during his papacy.
The most notable and immediate response to Pope Leo’s inaugural Mass was his use of the English language, particularly his Chicago accent. Traditionally, popes have been recognized for their Italian accents, reflecting the Vatican’s deep historical and cultural ties. Consequently, Pope Leo’s American accent during his first address was an unforeseen occurrence that elicited significant reactions from the audience.
A user on X commented, “The new Pope addressing us in English with an American accent! What a shock for me.” Another post humorously noted, “The Pope is conversing in English, with an American accent.” The public’s response was predominantly one of astonishment, with numerous individuals observing that the concept of an American pope speaking English appeared to diverge from centuries of established tradition.
Certain users expressed amusement at the American accent, with one remarking, ‘The Pope will have an American accent, and for some reason, that is making me laugh more than anything else. The Pope should not possess an American accent.’ Another comment reflected a similar view, stating, ‘It is simply not possible to be Pope if one has an American accent.’
Nonetheless, some individuals promptly emphasized the cultural importance of the occasion. One individual remarked, ‘A Pope with an American accent is quite intriguing from a cultural perspective,’ while another responded, ‘An American pope possessing an American accent feels somewhat unsettling to me…’
The varied reactions signify a larger cultural and social transformation that the Catholic Church is experiencing under the leadership of Pope Leo. His election as the first American pope represents not merely a symbolic milestone but also a sign that the Church is adapting to better represent the diverse global community of its adherents, including those from the United States.
Pope Leo is generally regarded as a centrist regarding Catholic social matters, especially those related to poverty, immigration, and the LGBTQ+ community. His perspectives are closely aligned with those of Pope Francis, particularly in advocating for the marginalized and disadvantaged. Pope Leo has expressed strong support for social justice, focusing on immigration, climate change, and the involvement of women in the Church.
Pope Leo firmly believes in the importance of immigration and advocates for the rights of migrants. He has openly criticized the stringent immigration policies implemented by former U.S. President Donald Trump, particularly regarding the treatment of immigrant families at the U.S.-Mexico border.
Pope Leo has consistently urged for a more humane approach towards migrants and refugees, asserting that the Church must act as a voice for those who cannot speak for themselves. In a notable retweet from Cardinal Blase J. Cupich in 2018, he condemned Trump’s family separation policies, declaring: ‘There is nothing remotely Christian, American, or morally defensible about a policy that takes children away from their parents and warehouses them in cages.
This is being carried out in our name and the shame is on us all.’ His emphasis on immigration reflects his overarching commitment to social justice, which promotes dignity and respect for all individuals, irrespective of their origins or nationality.
Historically, Pope Leo has voiced concerns regarding the LGBTQ+ community, particularly in relation to the depiction of homosexuality in media and the Church’s position on same-sex relationships.
In 2012, he criticized the entertainment industry for endorsing what he referred to as ‘alternative families’ and the ‘homosexual lifestyle.’ It remains unclear whether his views have changed during his papacy, but there are signs that Pope Leo may embrace a more inclusive perspective in the future.
Given the shifting social landscape, it is probable that his stance on LGBTQ+ matters will continue to develop, and his papacy will be closely examined as advocates for LGBTQ+ rights seek more inclusive policies within the Church.
Pope Leo’s affiliation with the Order of St. Augustine has significantly influenced his perspective on poverty. This Order has a longstanding commitment to service, which Pope Leo has embraced by prioritizing the reduction of poverty and supporting marginalized communities.
His papacy is expected to uphold this commitment, emphasizing the Church’s responsibility to care for the impoverished and promote systemic reforms to combat economic disparity. Pope Leo has highlighted the importance of the Church adhering to its principles regarding poverty and addressing the needs of the most vulnerable. His approach to leadership is anticipated to focus on social outreach, community engagement, and advocacy for individuals experiencing poverty.
Pope Leo’s perspective on the involvement of women in the Church has attracted considerable interest. In 2023, he expressed support for women’s roles in Church leadership, emphasizing that their insights have enhanced the Church’s mission. Notably, Pope Leo endorsed Pope Francis’ historic decision to permit women to participate in the Dicastery for Bishops. This decision represents a pivotal advancement in the ongoing dialogue regarding women’s positions within the Catholic Church, and Pope Leo’s persistent support for their inclusion will be monitored closely.
Pope Leo has issued emphatic declarations regarding the necessity for decisive measures to combat climate change. In 2024, he urged a transition from mere words to tangible actions, highlighting the importance of implementing specific strategies to tackle the environmental crisis confronting the Earth. His position on climate change underscores the increasing urgency of ecological concerns and is in harmony with Pope Francis’ significant encyclical on the environment, Laudato Si’. It is anticipated that Pope Leo’s leadership will persist in prioritizing environmental stewardship as a fundamental principle of his papacy.
The election of Pope Leo as the inaugural American pope signifies a pivotal moment for the Catholic Church. His leadership is expected to introduce innovative viewpoints on essential matters including immigration, poverty, climate change, and social justice. Although his Chicago accent and American heritage have drawn some attention, Pope Leo’s papacy heralds a new age of inclusivity and interaction with contemporary society.
As Pope Leo addresses the intricacies of Church leadership, his perspectives on LGBTQ+ rights, the role of women within the Church, and his support for marginalized communities will influence his legacy. His dedication to social justice and the Church’s involvement in tackling global issues will characterize his papacy for years ahead, creating a profound effect on both the faithful and the broader world.